The window to turn down this winter's Winter Fuel Payment in England, Wales and Northern Ireland closed in September. So if you were born on or before 27 June 1960 and your income for this tax year is over £35,000, the money will still arrive in November or December, and HMRC will then take all of it back. That's nothing to lose sleep over, but it's worth knowing how they'll do it, because for a lot of people the tax taken from their pension goes up noticeably from January.
Can I still turn down this winter's payment?
Not in England, Wales or Northern Ireland. The opt-out for winter 2026 to 2027 has closed, and the window for winter 2027 to 2028 opens on 21 December 2026.
Scotland works differently. There the payment is the Pension Age Winter Heating Payment, run by Social Security Scotland, and its online opt-out form stays open until midday on 19 October 2026. The same £35,000 charge applies to it, so if you live in Scotland and you're over the line, there are still a few days to decide.
Will HMRC take the payment back from me?
Yes, if your total income for the 2026 to 2027 tax year is over £35,000. The tax year runs from 6 April 2026 to 5 April 2027, so it's this year's income that counts, not last year's.
Three things about the test catch people out:
- It's all or nothing. There's no sliding scale. A pound over £35,000 and the whole payment goes back, which is between £100 and £300 depending on your age and who you live with.
- It's your income, not your household's. Your partner's income doesn't count towards yours, so in a couple one of you can be over the line and the other not.
- Some benefits switch the charge off. If you got Pension Credit, Universal Credit, income-related Employment and Support Allowance, income-based Jobseeker's Allowance or Income Support in the qualifying week of 21 to 27 September 2026, there's no charge, whatever your income.
What counts towards the £35,000?
Your taxable income before any deductions. HMRC's own checker asks about your State Pension, private and workplace pensions, wages, self-employment, rental profits, savings interest, dividends and taxable benefits, so all of those go in.
Two of them deserve a closer look:
- Rental profit is worked out HMRC's way, not your bank account's. You take off either the £1,000 property allowance or your allowable expenses, but mortgage interest doesn't come off. A landlord whose rent barely covers the mortgage can still have a taxable profit that tips them over. Income from letting a room in your own home under Rent a Room is left out.
- Pension withdrawals count. A taxable lump sum or drawdown payment from a private pension is income in the year you take it. If you're close to the line, a withdrawal that pushes you over costs you the whole Winter Fuel Payment on top of the tax on the withdrawal itself.
If you're not sure which side of the line you're on, HMRC's winter payment checker works it out from what you expect to receive. If property is part of the picture, this is the kind of thing our landlord tax service covers every year.
How will HMRC collect it?
Through your tax code, unless you file a Self Assessment tax return. HMRC will write or email to say your code has changed, and the extra tax then comes out of your pension or wages over the following months. If they can't collect it all within the tax year, you'll get a tax calculation letter for the rest.
If you do file a return, the charge goes on that instead. Online returns usually fill it in for you as the "Winter Fuel Payment charge" and add it to your bill, but it's still your responsibility to include it, so check it's there and that it matches what you were paid. Our personal tax returns service picks this up as a matter of course.
If you've moved onto Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, you can't pay the charge through your software. HMRC write to you after you've submitted, with the amount and how to pay, and their advice is to wait for that letter rather than trying to pay early.
Why might my tax go up more than I expected in January?
Because a lot of people will be paying back two winters at once. If HMRC are already collecting last winter's payment through your tax code, they'll change your code again in January 2027 to start on this winter's as well. GOV.UK puts that at roughly £30 to £33 a month in extra tax where both payments were £200.
In April 2027 the code changes again, to finish this winter's payment and start collecting next winter's in advance. That's HMRC moving everyone onto paying the charge in the same year as the payment, and their figures have it settling back to around £17 a month on a £200 payment once the catch-up is done. The exact months have shifted since HMRC first set this out, so go by the coding notice you're actually sent rather than any figure you've read.
The one thing we'd do when that notice arrives is look at the income HMRC have estimated for you. If it's wrong and you'll actually be under £35,000 this year, tell them and get the code corrected now, rather than overpaying for months and waiting for it to come back.
Is it worth opting out next winter?
For most people comfortably over the line, yes, though not because it saves money. If your income is over £35,000 you pay the whole thing back either way, so opting out doesn't change where you end up. What it does is take the round trip away: no payment in, no tax code change to collect it, nothing to check on a return.
The opt-out for winter 2027 to 2028 opens on 21 December 2026, and once you've opted out it stays in place until you opt back in. That's worth remembering if your income drops later. If you opted out last year and your income this year will be £35,000 or less, you can opt back in for this winter by contacting the Winter Fuel Payment Centre on 0800 731 0160 before 31 March 2027.
If you're near the line rather than well over it, it's a judgement call, and a quick look at the year ahead with us is the easiest way to make it. Get in touch and we'll talk it through.

